Planet Rugby Forum

What a lazy shite effort from Smith there to try and charge that kick down. He was walking!

Holding on Sir

Enzedder wrote:Holding on Sir

Gardner's performance at the tackle area has been very one sided.

It's actually become a hell of a game!

Phew, eh?

this is the sharks saders finish again.

Bad luck Angus - you tried

Weak by Gardner at the end. “Down by Red”

Good game do we need a royal commission regarding the penalty count?

Great defence, Chiefs.

A moment of white line fever from one of the fatties possibly cost the Reds at the end, mind the they still needed to crack the line elsewhere.

Ardron is a terrific player.

Now can I bitch and moan about the Chiefs disallowed try?

p.s. I had no problem with the 2 disallowed tries from the reds.

Ted. wrote:Great defence, Chiefs.

A moment of white line fever from one of the fatties possibly cost the Reds at the end, mind the they still needed to crack the line elsewhere.

Didn’t make the most of the advantage calls. Pick and goes are easily defended. Set 2 out from the ruck and have options

Enzedder wrote:Bad luck Angus - you tried

Certainly did after the final maul collapse, gave the Reds a few minutes to dig the ball out, should've been scrum Chiefs and game over.

Crazy Ed wrote:Good game do we need a royal commission regarding the penalty count?

That would depend on whether it became a consistent feature of games officiated by Australian refs involving Australian teams. If it did over a few game it might raise eyebrows. If it happened in every single season of Super Rugby, well, I’m not sure what you’d call that

We kept on making incredible last ditch turnovers then kicking the ball straight back down their throats.

Really impressive ball retention from the Reds. We were lucky they struggled to manipulate the back line defence

Webber didn't think the discipline was good but I thought the Chiefs defended with a lot of discipline especially in the first half. Some lazy offsides in the second but considering how many tackles they made I thought for large periods they were very solid.

All that said, the Reds did well at keeping possession but they didn't really challenge the Chiefs much, I've seen harder attacking systems to defend against.

Going to be a really long year, next year without Kerevi. Without him the reds back line is completely toothless.

Toro wrote:

Enzedder wrote:Bad luck Angus - you tried

Certainly did after the final maul collapse, gave the Reds a few minutes to dig the ball out, should've been scrum Chiefs and game over.

Should have been a yellow card. Close to a penalty try.

FairWeather_Aussie wrote:Going to be a really long year, next year without Kerevi. Without him the reds back line is completely toothless.

Where is he going? A young Petaia back, Mcgahan in full fitness, won't be too bad I suppose.

Macrosan wrote:

Brumbieman wrote:How the fudge can a country with AFL as it's most popular winter sport produce such f**king appalling kickers in rugby? It's genuinely embarrassing how useless our kickers are.

This.

Very bewildering why they do not have a kicking coach.

The strange thing is that the Red's kicking coach is Dave Aldred, Jonny Wilkinson's kicking coach and with as much claim as anyone to be the best in the world. All I can imagine is that his reputation is based on his knowledge of place kicking, but even that is in question after BHs's 1-from-6 performance last week. I think AFL doesn't aid someone with rugby kicking anywhere near as much as soccer does, as AFL kicking is very approximate compared to what's required in rugby - kick the ball into a general area for someone to run onto, or kick the ball high above a pack for someone to leap for. That's my best guess, anyhow.

That last ruck at the end of the game - looked very much like he got the ball down on the line.

As per usual this year, I missed the second half of the game

Very glad to see the good guys get a win out of this one, a quick look a the play-by-play makes it look like the Chiefs had to do a shit ton of defensive work in the 2nd, glad they held on.
Handling still seems to be a slippery area for the Chiefs, I'm getting fondly reminiscent of those halcyon days when they could throw the ball about with reckless abandon and some team mate would miraculously be there to catch it.

Any update on the Reds prop who got injured in the first, were they were doing spinal precautions? Hope he's ok.

How good was Sam Cane Boshier is seriously good and would not let down black at the WC

Both superb, but Boshier playing full 80 & arguably singlehandedly kept Chiefs in the contest in second half. Just brilliant

How good was Moli? Has to be in ab contention

Enzedder wrote:Now can I bitch and moan about the Chiefs disallowed try?

p.s. I had no problem with the 2 disallowed tries from the reds.

swc wrote:How good was Moli? Has to be in ab contention

Moli is the form prop in the country. The selectors have to be interested

naki wrote:

swc wrote:How good was Moli? Has to be in ab contention

Moli is the form prop in the country. The selectors have to be interested

I've lost track of the injury status of our front row stocks. It'll be nice to have some more quality options like Moli stepping up.

Turbogoat wrote:

naki wrote:

swc wrote:How good was Moli? Has to be in ab contention

Moli is the form prop in the country. The selectors have to be interested

I've lost track of the injury status of our front row stocks. It'll be nice to have some more quality options like Moli stepping up.

Moody is fine, will be back soon. Franks is still a couple of weeks away.

The other contenders (Big Karl, Ofa, Laulala) are all fit.

Moli is outplaying all of them at the moment

naki wrote:

Turbogoat wrote:

naki wrote:

swc wrote:How good was Moli? Has to be in ab contention

Moli is the form prop in the country. The selectors have to be interested

I've lost track of the injury status of our front row stocks. It'll be nice to have some more quality options like Moli stepping up.

Moody is fine, will be back soon. Franks is still a couple of weeks away.

The other contenders (Big Karl, Ofa, Laulala) are all fit.

Moli is outplaying all of them at the moment

What is the story with Hames?

obelixtim wrote:

naki wrote:

Turbogoat wrote:

naki wrote:

swc wrote:How good was Moli? Has to be in ab contention

Moli is the form prop in the country. The selectors have to be interested

I've lost track of the injury status of our front row stocks. It'll be nice to have some more quality options like Moli stepping up.

Moody is fine, will be back soon. Franks is still a couple of weeks away.

The other contenders (Big Karl, Ofa, Laulala) are all fit.

Moli is outplaying all of them at the moment

What is the story with Hames?

In the squad but ongoing concussion symptoms

I have picked up another Chiefs player as a client who won't make it back (hence the referral to me) dammit. One of the times when you don't want a client

Jensrsa wrote:

Enzedder wrote:Now can I bitch and moan about the Chiefs disallowed try?

p.s. I had no problem with the 2 disallowed tries from the reds.

Wow, great photo. TMO got everything spot on, if you watch that try in real time seemed like an incredibly tough call.

Edit: looks like it was after the initial 'try'.

saturo has bombed a few tries like that this season, so he definitely bomb that too..

Lachlan Boshier was extremely impressive in the final 10 mins, when the Chiefs were under seige.

Toro wrote:

Jensrsa wrote:

Enzedder wrote:Now can I bitch and moan about the Chiefs disallowed try?

p.s. I had no problem with the 2 disallowed tries from the reds.

Wow, great photo. TMO got everything spot on, if you watch that try in real time seemed like an incredibly tough call.

Edit: looks like it was after the initial 'try'.

That was my thought too - still shots are like a black glove.

Enzedder wrote:

obelixtim wrote:

naki wrote:

Turbogoat wrote:

naki wrote: Moli is the form prop in the country. The selectors have to be interested

I've lost track of the injury status of our front row stocks. It'll be nice to have some more quality options like Moli stepping up.

Moody is fine, will be back soon. Franks is still a couple of weeks away.

The other contenders (Big Karl, Ofa, Laulala) are all fit.

Moli is outplaying all of them at the moment

What is the story with Hames?

In the squad but ongoing concussion symptoms

I have picked up another Chiefs player as a client who won't make it back (hence the referral to me) dammit. One of the times when you don't want a client

Is it McNicol, if you can''t say, wink once for yes and twice for no. (Please be no, he was scheduled to return for the Magpies in the NPC).

Enzedder wrote:

Although, bummer for the player it is.

Enzedder wrote:

Toro wrote:

Jensrsa wrote:

Enzedder wrote:Now can I bitch and moan about the Chiefs disallowed try?

p.s. I had no problem with the 2 disallowed tries from the reds.

Wow, great photo. TMO got everything spot on, if you watch that try in real time seemed like an incredibly tough call.

Edit: looks like it was after the initial 'try'.

That was my thought too - still shots are like a black glove.

A replay that no-one but the TMO saw was the reason for the baffling no-try decision against the Chiefs on Friday night.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/sup ... denied-try

Apart from the fact that the front on replays showed that he lost the ball