Planet Rugby Forum

Wilderbeast

I don’t like mo at ten, and that’s mainly due to the casual disregard he is showing nz rugby and the all blacks. If he makes himself available after the Japanese contract ends, I reckon any previous all blacks coach would tell him to fudge himself. Robertson though? I don’t know. He clearly wanted h...

Wilderbeast

xhooker wrote: ↑Sun Jul 13, 2025 12:24 am Why is the 4th-best Lock Captain of the All Blacks?

Is this based on 1-2 games against a sub-strength French team?

Wilderbeast

BB is clearly kicking according to a defined gameplan and he wasn’t the only one. It’s surprising how often people are bringing this up as a criticism. If you want to criticise him, criticise the accuracy of his kicks, not the frequency.

Wilderbeast

It’s not as important as you all think if we are targeting the next rwc. Far more important to get the current gen’s comfortable in whatever new system Robertson is introducing.

Wilderbeast

What year is mounga eligible for selection? Is it 2026 or 2027?

Wilderbeast

jdogscoop wrote: ↑Sun Jul 06, 2025 6:40 am
Wilderbeast wrote: ↑Sun Jul 06, 2025 6:14 am
jdogscoop wrote: ↑Sat Jul 05, 2025 11:52 pm It's bloody lucky we won. A cursory glance around the forum shows how much the "neutrals" would have been dining out on the result if we'd lost.
Did we watch the same game?
I presume so. You may be taking my comments a little too literally though. Note the rest of my post.

Wilderbeast

jdogscoop wrote: ↑Sat Jul 05, 2025 11:52 pm It's bloody lucky we won. A cursory glance around the forum shows how much the "neutrals" would have been dining out on the result if we'd lost.

Did we watch the same game?

Wilderbeast

I don’t rate Reece much but one thing he does well is chase kicks. We seriously missed that last night. It frustrates me as it’s something that should be a winger's bread and butter and I shouldn’t be praising anyone for it. It should be expected.

Wilderbeast

booji boy wrote: ↑Sat Jul 05, 2025 9:11 pm
True Blue wrote: ↑Sat Jul 05, 2025 9:08 pm
booji boy wrote: ↑Sat Jul 05, 2025 9:04 pm

If they drop him and Beauden Barrett and with Akira already plying his trade offshore what would you have left to post about?
They'll probably blame the Auckland physio
The AB's have an Auckland physio?

This explains everything.

Wilderbeast

Typically untidy first test of the year. If we’re that bad again next week I’ll worry, but no stress for now. We did well to adjust our game in the last 15 and hold on, a Fozzie team loses this one by playing the same way all test and turning down that three. The big positive is Holland. A revelati...

Wilderbeast

Is Beauden now higher on the 10 pecking order than McKenzie ? Will he make the squad up to the next RWC or are you getting Richie back ? Ritchie will be back with Love elevated . I dunno, he will be coming into the team cold in World Cup year won’t he? Not many coaches would pick from that but we k...

Wilderbeast

Crusaders players that Scott Robertson could conceivably have selected, but didn't: - George Bower - George Bell - Ioane Moananu - Ethan Blackadder - Christian Lio-Willie - Rivez Reihana - David Havili - Braydon Ennor - Chay Fihaki Everyone satisfied? Will that be the end of that narrative? The fac...

Wilderbeast

Having Mo’unga, DMac, BB as options at 10 in 2027 isn’t bad. But what happens if we have a situation like 2011 again, when Carter, Slade and Cruden all got crocked? One of the young 10s needs to be given significant time in the squad before then. What if we develop two more 10s but all five get inj...

Wilderbeast

An interesting opinion piece about ways NZR could better promote the game of Rugby and especially increase the interest of youths. https://sportnation.nz/article/as-i-see-it-three-quick-fixes-to-reignite-new-zealands-passion-for-rugby?fbclid=IwY2xjawIGV1pleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHRNjlFUXq_viftQVEg0SoqgHyMn...

Wilderbeast

Well this thread has taken an entertaining turn the last page or two. From plain old Mounga trolling we've now widened the scope to Sevu Reece, Frizzell, Akira Ioane, Foster, Cane and Ryan. :lol: :thumbup: Did i leave anyone out? BB made an appearance a few post up from this one. A failed attempt, ...

Wilderbeast

BB was always the better 10, this confirms it.

Wilderbeast

Ali's Choice wrote: ↑Tue Dec 17, 2024 12:31 am
TEDS wrote: ↑Tue Dec 17, 2024 12:21 am Unfortunately we have to wait 6 months before we get to try any of this because Stead wouldn't give it a go in a dead and meaningless test
Stead doesn't decide how many tests we play.

Btw, I don't think any test is meaningless.

Correct, no test is meaningless.

Wilderbeast

jambanja wrote: ↑Mon Dec 16, 2024 6:33 am What the fuck are the Black Caps doing, why aren’t England batting yet, this is ridiculous

This England team is never batting 2 days for a draw.

Wilderbeast

Says he wants to coach England, France, or Ireland - but definitely not Wales :lol: It would be a dereliction of duties if Razor didn't at least extend the invite and see if he was interested. I assume he probably wouldn't accept, but you've got to at least ask. They clearly have a pre-existing rel...

Wilderbeast

Top14 has a finals format right? Don’t they get 80k crowds for that?

Wilderbeast

Best comment in this entire thread. Read it and weep Ali's Choice and Mr Brownstone. Except it's based on revisionism and with the benefit of hindsight. At the end of the SR season, no-one was calling for Sititi to be our starting All Black no.6. Even the most loathsome of Chiefs trolls weren't cal...

Wilderbeast

Bands 1. Queensryche 2. Queens of the Stone Age 3. Taylor swift 4. Noel Gallagher 5. Beyoncé Top 5 songs all from operation mindcrime. I discovered queensryche this year and loved them, thrashing multiple albums but none quite like operation mindcrime. I’m a fan of everything on the list but Taylor ...

Wilderbeast

I love Metallica, but their discography is so much weaker than it should be given their status.

Wilderbeast

There you go... sounds like he just felt like there were three ahead of him... fair enough. He was probably right... https://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/harry-plummer-reveals-reasons-for-leaving-new-zealand-rugby-next-year/2P7N4AMMDZCQXD5F2AKJVI4XZI/ Three ahead of him yet one of them isn't even eligi...

Wilderbeast

Why are we picking this guy? Wasn’t MacDonald against it? Was he? I don't remember reading any suggestion of this; got a source? There is no source. It was a ridiculous idea dreamt up by a North Island based troll in the Razor Out thread. That McDonald was fired because he took a noble, moral stand...

Wilderbeast

Why are we picking this guy? Wasn’t MacDonald against it?

Wilderbeast

Short Man Syndrome wrote: ↑Sun Dec 01, 2024 8:14 am Dave was always the best guitarist in Megadeth.

That’s quite a take, and I rate Mustaine.

Wilderbeast

And the Heralds' team of the year. https://archive.ph/z1WOI Two things stand out to me I truly think the media made so much noise about Jordan being a fullback all year that they had their puff pieces written already before any games were played. He hasn’t set the world alight, and his best tests h...

Wilderbeast

And the Heralds' team of the year. https://archive.ph/z1WOI Two things stand out to me I truly think the media made so much noise about Jordan being a fullback all year that they had their puff pieces written already before any games were played. He hasn’t set the world alight, and his best tests h...

Wilderbeast

I am quite happy with Robertson’s job to date. I just don’t want to move away from how we currently manage overseas based players.

Wilderbeast

This thread is an interesting example of people listing achievements (awards and trophies) vs how well they actually played and how long they were considered number one. It’s interesting how the SH view DuPont as well. We simply don’t see him as often as NH viewers do, and I understand that’s mainl...

Wilderbeast

not_english wrote: ↑Fri Nov 29, 2024 11:20 pm Not watched NZ cricket for a while, but good God these commentators are awful.

Who is it? And why are they terrible?

Wilderbeast

Of course we all know it’s really only about Richie Mo’unga. That’s been transparently obvious from the start. Mr B’s claims that being able to call on Isaac Ross, Richard Kahui and Chase Tiatia would remedy All Black issues were a silly smokescreen we all saw through from the get-go. It’s pretty o...

Wilderbeast

This thread is an interesting example of people listing achievements (awards and trophies) vs how well they actually played and how long they were considered number one. It’s interesting how the SH view DuPont as well. We simply don’t see him as often as NH viewers do, and I understand that’s mainly...

Wilderbeast

Roberston seems to have been driven in a quest for immediate results without considering the future. Players like Lakai, Love, Kirifi, Proctor, Lam, Holland... et al should all been developed further - yet were passed over to give "reward" to players at the end of their careers. Robertson's fundame...

Wilderbeast

I can see the allure of a huge pay check in signing for three seasons. But RMo still could have made a fair bit—and not taken himself out of the NZ picture for so long—by just taking a sabbatical or compromising and just signing up for two years. As AC has already pointed out, these top ABs aren’t ...

Wilderbeast

I believe Mo’unga made a bad call to sign up for three years in Japan. Putting aside the whole AB selection debate. It was a silly call for him and his family. Watching the podcast interview with him it’s clear that while there are things about Japan he enjoys (he claims at one stage that he and hi...

Wilderbeast

Yeah that's a massive, overlooked factor. It's a lot, lot easier to turn down a massive overseas contract if you were born into a comfortable/affluent/privileged family and are already earning good money in NZ. Maybe you already have a cushy-post rugby career set up in the media/coaching and you'll...

Wilderbeast

Star Wars. The originals is the most overrated trilogy in Cinema history, and the others are either mildless dross or actual human excrement. It's not actually sci fi, yet is somehow the poster child for it. How is it not sci fi? It's space fantasy. There is nothing science about it, everything run...

Wilderbeast

Zakar wrote: ↑Wed Nov 27, 2024 8:37 pm Star Wars. The originals is the most overrated trilogy in Cinema history, and the others are either mildless dross or actual human excrement.

It's not actually sci fi, yet is somehow the poster child for it.

How is it not sci fi?

Search found 6301 matches