Planet Rugby Forum

CM11

I seem to remember a Leinster team losing out in SA by more than 50 pts last season... If that's not disrespecting the the league by a team that amassed the most points I don't know what is. Disrespecting the league would be what Munster used to do when they were still able to challenge in Europe (...

CM11

The point still stands, Leinster send out teams that short change the local supporters. The team was fine. How they played on the other hand..... Of all the teams to accuse of not respecting the league, Leinster would be well down the list. What with only ever been out of the top 4 (3 actually, I t...

CM11

OK but imo, Munster are much more popular visitors down there than Leinster on account of showing those fixtures more respect. Respect as they are either out of Europe or desperately need the League points... The point still stands, Leinster send out teams that short change the local supporters. Th...

CM11

Yeah you’re hanging onto life there with your 7week holidays to Lanzarote Not all in Lanzarote, Portugal is a Possibility. Going to Amalfi. in October, Killaloe this weekend. I volunteer 2 or 3 hours in the morning twice a week at an addiction centre. At 72 I still work and earn because I like the ...

CM11

Can someone please tell me why the state is on the hook for redress from the Stardust? Obviously an awful disaster but why are the tax payer footing the bill? I agree with them on this. They were shamefully denied justice for over 40 years. It was a f**king disgrace. Pay up and let them move on. De...

CM11

I have good news for you!

CM11

AJ Your viewpoint on this isn't exactly controversial but if the argument is to achieve what's best for society then a lot of these people just need to not be around anymore. At all. Of course that's a whole other can of worms. The problem is that when you argue against prison for serial criminals, ...

CM11

Cam has in the past blown a fair bit of smoke up McGrath's ass but I fail to see what's controversial about what he said? - McGrath was always good for a few poor passes - he is a good rugby player - he was the first decent SH we produced since Scally - he does have 19 caps (and went to WC 2019 as ...

CM11

feckwanker wrote: ↑Tue Apr 23, 2024 8:34 am So have the Lions got their shit together or was the Leinster game an aberration?

Don't give them easy ball to attack off. We had enough possession and territory to win the game.

CM11

Cam has in the past blown a fair bit of smoke up McGrath's ass but I fail to see what's controversial about what he said? - McGrath was always good for a few poor passes - he is a good rugby player - he was the first decent SH we produced since Scally - he does have 19 caps (and went to WC 2019 as o...

CM11

OupaStruisbaai wrote: ↑Mon Apr 22, 2024 2:52 pm Top of the weekend clash. Leinster the big favorites

CM11

He seems to have lost power in his pass which just adds to the chances of a poor pass, something he was never very able to avoid anyway.

CM11

Unfortunately the halfbacks who should have given a bit of cohesion to the game weren't very good and some of the young players such as Osborne and Brownlee were, simply, awful. Both very young of course but if Brownlee is going to Munster I'm not sure that he'll be that much of a loss from what I'...

CM11

https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/2024/04/22/shotgun-seized-by-gardai-in-2009-finds-its-way-back-into-criminal-hands/ Stories like this don't half harm the idea we need to be sympathetic to the Gardai against Harris. Do you mean Harris is right to have the rank and file on a choke chain? I don't...

CM11

One way to look at the stats is that our inept attack kept the ball away from the Lions for significant periods of time and thus kept the score down. :lol: They basically scored anytime they got the ball. Would be nice to have some genuine pace though. Watching our players trying to keep up was dep...

CM11

Unfortunately the halfbacks who should have given a bit of cohesion to the game weren't very good and some of the young players such as Osborne and Brownlee were, simply, awful. Both very young of course but if Brownlee is going to Munster I'm not sure that he'll be that much of a loss from what I'...

CM11

Worst bit is, that with a bit of composure, Leinster could have been right in that match. Did you see the match stats? Whatever about losing, the scoreline is awful given how much ball we had. I would say nearly all their tries came of 1/2 phases and mainly turnover ball. All of the SA teams have l...

CM11

https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/20 ... nal-hands/

Stories like this don't half harm the idea we need to be sympathetic to the Gardai against Harris.

CM11

McGrath is a good rugby player but not an especially good passer for a SH. The seasons where he did well for us he always had a run of games to crisp up his delivery. Between injuries and being down the pecking order has meant that his service is way off where it should be at this time of the year....

CM11

It’s a recurring theme based on McGrath’s season to date but it really is essential that JGP stays fit. McGrath is a good rugby player but not an especially good passer for a SH. The seasons where he did well for us he always had a run of games to crisp up his delivery. Between injuries and being d...

CM11

Back of a cig packet calculations gives me a top 8 of Leinster Glasgow Munster Bulls Stormers Edinburgh Ulster Treviso Top 5 are going to be around those 5, with a lot of permutations deciding order (I have Leinster/Glasgow both on 68 with same amount of wins and PD almost identical). Bottom 3 squea...

CM11

Floppy finding fault with something, say it ain't so!

CM11

The alleged cooney knock on was not foul play so was not reviewable. The carre knock onwas intentional(and it was a knock on) so it was reviewable, learn the laws If it's within two phases anything can be reviewed. I didn't see the questionable try, was the knock on within two phases? I think we sc...

CM11

Still plenty to play for but that Munster win has given both Leinster and Glasgow some breathing room.

CM11

Thought Cardiff were done there. Thought you Welsh and Scots were mates Its not whether the calls right, there was a knock on from cooney prior to ulcers try and our captain asked for it to be reviewed and it wasn't. Adamson was gagging to review the last play, its so f**king corrupt. This si why w...

CM11

Well done and thanks Munster. Decent weekend so far for the provinces.

CM11

iarmhiman wrote: ↑Sat Apr 20, 2024 2:53 pm If that's a shoulder injury for Osbourne , then he could miss the semi final

You know it's his brother?

CM11

iarmhiman wrote: ↑Sat Apr 20, 2024 2:45 pm That's a shocking decision by the officials

TMO's hands tied once onfield decision was no try.

CM11

Robbed!!

CM11

Point of order, 22-0.

CM11

Yikes.

This is traumatising my 8 year old!

CM11

We're still back in Dublin.

Pity, this side should be doing better.

CM11

No one watching?

Lions score from kick off. 7-0.

CM11

So Munster's "Wah, wah, it's not fair " strop worked then. Leinster, with most players on a central contract, will have to contribute most to this 'pot', thus penalising them for developing players, with the contents of this pot being distributed to Munster and Ulster, whose first instinct is to re...

CM11

Just looking at the table, Cardiff now have 11 BP from 14 games but only 3 wins. They've also had a draw. Their PD is only marginally negative. Must be hard to keep on getting the wrong side of close matches but equally it's good to see they've been competitive in nearly every game. Hopefully they c...

CM11

Luckycharmer wrote: ↑Fri Apr 19, 2024 10:53 pm
CM11 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 19, 2024 10:36 pm Not sure about the uproar regarding the last penalty. Looks like a deliberate knock on to me?
Except no conclusive evidence he even touched the ball.

You think the TMO only looked at the pics we saw and didn't check for whether he touched it?

CM11

Not sure about the uproar regarding the last penalty. Looks like a deliberate knock on to me?

CM11

Murphy will need a lot of time to fix this rabble. I'm not sure what the Ulster lads expect. It's rare a coach can instantly fix systemic problems with a side. This isn't a side who were pretty good who lost their way. It's a side who finished the season 2nd in the league last season and apparently...

CM11

irishrugbyua wrote: ↑Fri Apr 19, 2024 8:22 pm
iarmhiman wrote: ↑Fri Apr 19, 2024 8:21 pm Murphy will need a lot of time to fix this rabble.
will he get the chance? rumoured that Payne may be Ulsters choice

Possibly the better choice.

CM11

iarmhiman wrote: ↑Fri Apr 19, 2024 8:21 pm Murphy will need a lot of time to fix this rabble.

I'm not sure what the Ulster lads expect. It's rare a coach can instantly fix systemic problems with a side. This isn't a side who were pretty good who lost their way.

Search found 84185 matches