Planet Rugby Forum

madman

She's a woman. You can say she has a condition that means she shouldn't be boxing against other women who do not have that condition. But she is a woman. well the test Imane Khelif had to take indicated she was male with a disorder that meant Imane Khelif was a male who presented as a female, simil...

madman

She cheated by competing against women and she is a man. She's a woman. You can say she has a condition that means she shouldn't be boxing against other women who do not have that condition. But she is a woman. The is patently untrue. Just untrue. He’s a man. With testes and a DSD. do not read the ...

madman

I feel quite sorry for Imane Khelif, shes done nothing and now some pieces of shit won't even use her name. She cheated by competing against women and she is a man. She's a woman. You can say she has a condition that means she shouldn't be boxing against other women who do not have that condition. ...

madman

I feel quite sorry for Imane Khelif, shes done nothing and now some pieces of shit won't even use her name. She cheated by competing against women and she is a man. Honestly, that is a twelve year old's response: "He / she is a cheat, the big cheater!" Imane Khelif is most likely one of those relat...

madman

Why are you discussing this in a transgender thread? https://www.si.com/fannation/boxing/world-boxing-mandates-controversial-testing-of-olympic-gold-medalist-imane-khelif-in-order-to-compete I think the correct answer to his question is because the trans movement long ago co-opted Intersex people a...

madman

Wut....i don't think anyone gives a fcuk about the west's expectations than the west anymore. Let the Chinese people decide. A bit hard to decide what they think about the day when you can't publicly discuss it without repercussions - that's if they are lucky to know about it at all. I showed a pho...

madman

Don't think they should be taking PEDs and competing at a social/amateur level either. The distinction here is not male vs female. Male competitions do not need to be exclusively male. They should be considered open competitions anyone can compete in. There is no need to exclude anyone who wants to...

madman

There was one of those "women's rights" protests in Melbourne the other week... Just a small group of ultra-conservatives, MAGA types, religious zealots, far-right agitators... just, you know - regular folk. It was great to see this small group of... mostly men... out there defending the rights of ...

madman

There was one of those "women's rights" protests in Melbourne the other week... Just a small group of ultra-conservatives, MAGA types, religious zealots, far-right agitators... just, you know - regular folk. It was great to see this small group of... mostly men... out there defending the rights of ...

madman

You say that, but what about the people who look like women in every way, born with a vagina and a fully functioning womb but also a pair of tiny unformed testicles somewhere inside their body? How can they possibly know which loo they should be using? It very rare and they can use women's toilet a...

madman

You say that, but what about the people who look like women in every way, born with a vagina and a fully functioning womb but also a pair of tiny unformed testicles somewhere inside their body? How can they possibly know which loo they should be using? It very rare and they can use women's toilet a...

madman

Argument by epithet. Very convincing. I suppose this girl needs to be told that having a trans man in her changing room is for the better good. https://x.com/theMRC/status/1913270197982560396?t=iodPDYONvHneqzqbGqmheQ&s=08 Be careful or the lefty nutjobs on here will be abusing you insisting that yo...

madman

Argument by epithet. Very convincing. I suppose this girl needs to be told that having a trans man in her changing room is for the better good. https://x.com/theMRC/status/1913270197982560396?t=iodPDYONvHneqzqbGqmheQ&s=08 I think you mean a trans woman. Multi tasking badly yes a trans women in chan...

madman

This is mansplaining of the highest order. These women's groups who appealed the decision to the Supreme Court, need to be told why upholding women's rights is in fact against their own best interests. They probably don't realise that keeping biological men out of toilets, changing rooms, rape cris...

madman

Are you guys seriously arguing that those who identify as men should be allowed in to womens spaces because you belive some women may be questioned?

And you see no risk in that to girls and women ?

madman

We're talking about a billionaire who dead names trans people and refuses to accept that trans people were targeted by Nazis in WW2, right? How trans people were treated by Nazis is not necessarily simple. The case below one competed for Germany in 1936. Although later was made to live as a man. He...

madman

I wouldn't say that accurate about Rowling. She hasn't harassed anyone online and only bites back at those who criticise or attacks her or supports males in female spaces. And she only started doing that after years of attacks for her position that biology matters in women's spaces. Something the S...

madman

Next weekend should be interesting.. another trip to Twickenham..
Do think France will give England a closer game than people expect.

madman

very good article in the observer https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/apr/20/the-supreme-court-has-carefully-ringfenced-protections-for-women-thats-all-we-wanted Middle-aged women are expected to fade into the background, to be apologetic for their existence, to quietly accept their lot....

madman

People like Graham Linehan just want to stand up to the madness and support women, and in time he will proven to be correct (along with Sharron Davies and JK Rowing etc). Its all perfectly reasonable and it's only confusing to people like you. Graham Lineham is a terminally online loser whose marri...

madman

Eugenius wrote: ↑Sun Apr 20, 2025 10:39 am I prefer to use the level of support given to a genocide as being a far more accurate barometer .

What are you on about?

madman

https://x.com/theMRC/status/19132701979 ... qmheQ&s=08

As Thomas said before peal clutches.. how dare a girl complain about a male in her changing room watching her undress. Obviously she is a bigot.

madman

Think this is a bit either naive or disingenuous as there's a massive amount of people claiming that this is their motivation when it's more likely they just find trans people a bit icky (or are on the grift like Gains). Irrelevant and unprovable. Just an open ended insult or allegation meant to de...

madman

The Pro-Girl Perspective: These individuals prioritise the experience and welfare of the 150 girls. From their point of view, the inclusion of one trans player could negatively affect the integrity, fairness, or safety of the game for the rest of the participants. Their concern isn’t rooted in host...

madman

Given the scenario of a girls' football league consisting of 10 teams, each with 15 players — a total of 150 girls. Now, suppose one of those teams includes a trans girl in their squad. Responses to this scenario generally fall into three distinct groups: The Pro-Girl Perspective: These individuals ...

madman

The thing is it used believe there was a was fair competition could ve inclusive.. then people like you convinced me it was impossible. Because you are anti women and girls. Your believe you are inclusive and nice. In the same way as all the people who protected the Rotherham rape gangs protected t...

madman

Do you think that maybe, the massive disinformation and anti-trans pr campaign being launched might just have something to do with it? The bathrooms angle wasn't getting the fucktards anywhere (rightly), so instead they've latched onto a topic that does have some small basis of validity to it and h...

madman

"Forced to accept individuals born male in their sport" sounds like you're concerned about fairness in competition, which is fair enough in many cases although I wouldn't make it a point of principle. If the administrators of a sport should decide that women and trans women can compete together fai...

madman

My issue with the anti-Trans people in sport folks, is that they are typically c**ts. They're typically arseholes. The kind of people who dislike gay people, dislike migrants and definitely dislike trans people. They use the trans in sports issue to justify their dislike of trans people in general....

madman

I can’t remember a more obscure edge-case that was ever raised to prominence. I used to think that some people worked hard to find things to get angry about, but now I know that they’re merely little puppets that will loyally go to battle for whatever manufactured crisis that Fox News came up with....

madman

It's only in certain sports and at the pinnacle of that sport that any advantage might be there, and sure, I'm more than open to a discussion about that, but the vast majority of people just want to go out there and have some fun with their friends on a Sunday afternoon and are being actively vilif...

madman

I find it super easy to go through life never thinking about Trans people in sport. Complete luxury obsession. Indeed. :thumbup: People get really worked up about it too. Real frothy mouthed energy. It's so f**king weird! It's really simple, if someone doesn't respect you for some bullshit arbitrar...

madman

It seems John Oliver just aired a show most claiming transwomen have no advantage in women's sports: https://x.com/ripx4nutmeg/status/1909136217377026129 Remember when he used to mock people for so obviously being against the Science or common sense? It kinda reminds me that so many people pick pos...

madman

Without Georgia being in the 6N, I think it would be great that the winner of the 6N B tournament gets to play a game at the beginning of the summer tour against the loser of the 6N A. As for Wales, we need them to come back. The 6N will become boring if they can't offer more than that. What makes ...

madman

https://www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/articles/cn04pz1wezyo Georgia head coach Richard Cockerill believes his side have "earned the right" to face Wales in a play-off to decide which nation should be in the 2026 Six Nations. - A fun bit of shit stirring.. A slightly desperate plea for attention, ta...

madman

Theflier wrote: ↑Tue Mar 18, 2025 1:38 pm As gash as we are, it still a marvel that only two countries have won the thing since we last did

Apart from Wales only 3 countries have ever won the six nations.

madman

https://www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/a ... 04pz1wezyo

Georgia head coach Richard Cockerill believes his side have "earned the right" to face Wales in a play-off to decide which nation should be in the 2026 Six Nations. - A fun bit of shit stirring..

madman

They beat them at Twickenham by the record margin of.... 1 point in a last minute try after France missed god know how many clear try scoring opportunities in the first half especially.........barely nothing to suggest they were superior to France even basing on that home game, other than the final...

madman

5 irish 3 kiwis 3 english 2 scots 1 saffa 1 welsh gatland spreading the selection about if we do get all irish coaching team I suspect we will get 10 or 11 irish in the test team-will cause issues for farrell if he doesnt. Interesting, but gatland would never pick that team if he was in charge. wou...

madman

Da iawn diolch wrote: ↑Mon Mar 17, 2025 3:07 pm I quite like the idea of annual trips to Lisbon and Madrid.

and the rest have Geogia, which is a long way to go, and the players are massive whist winning should be easy, injury is a real risk

Search found 1454 matches