Planet Rugby Forum

Ali's Choice

I'm excited about this test. Lots of different players being given a run. I'm happy that Ioane is no longer in the discussion for the 13 jersey. Excited about Love starting. Very happy to see Holland play again. If we play poorly I'll blame the high number of Chiefs players and relative lack of Crus...

Ali's Choice

BlueThunder wrote: ↑Fri Jul 18, 2025 4:27 am Dropping like flies.

It's definitely not ideal how many of our initial squad are injured.

Ali's Choice

I'd rate him ahead of Devery. I suspect a fair few non-Crusaders fans who didn't watch all our games aren't aware of just how good he was for us during the middle of the season. I'd go as far as saying if he wasn't playing for us this year we don't win the comp, because we wouldn't have earned as m...

Ali's Choice

I'd rate him ahead of Devery. I suspect a fair few non-Crusaders fans who didn't watch all our games aren't aware of just how good he was for us during the middle of the season. I'd go as far as saying if he wasn't playing for us this year we don't win the comp, because we wouldn't have earned as m...

Ali's Choice

I really like what we've done in selecting a 'spine' with an in-built combination. 2/8/9/10/12/13 are all Chiefs. This should help with cohesion in a somewhat experimental team. One thing I might have done is selected Jordan at 14 as an experienced head and calming voice at the back to help Love th...

Ali's Choice

I really like what we've done in selecting a 'spine' with an in-built combination. 2/8/9/10/12/13 are all Chiefs. This should help with cohesion in a somewhat experimental team. One thing I might have done is selected Jordan at 14 as an experienced head and calming voice at the back to help Love th...

Ali's Choice

Are we disrespecting France by selecting a B team?

Ali's Choice

I couldn't find the "Blues thread" but this is a joke surely... It has been their home ground since the inaugural Super Rugby season in 1996, but are the Blues’ Eden Park days numbered? The Auckland rugby franchise has begun canvassing the views of supporters on whether they would be in favour of a...

Ali's Choice

The Aumua experiment was a categorical failure. I don't know what happened, but we got sent a dud, not the player who was so destructive for MoPa. Happy, though surprised, to see Blackadder resign. Yeah the Aumua experiment was an abysmal failure. I can't believe how disappointing he was for us. I'...

Ali's Choice

Yes. 100% it was f-cking bizarre. I've never seen anyone in any other sport on earth in the history of television or radio or any other media just sit there sucking each other off over how good "their sport" is compared to other sports and how they're just shitting all over all the other sports in ...

Ali's Choice

Fair to say Bryn Evans’ appointment as lineout coach is looking astute after some of the moves and trick plays we’ve pulled so far? Our lineout looks better than it has since the peak Kieran Read era. Was at game, our lineout was bloody good, and having a couple of good size locks tend to give you ...

Ali's Choice

Just watching Fox NRL on stream because nothing else to do ... and wtf. These blokes are just sucking each other off over what a great thing is rugby league and how successful it is and how they're shitting on all the other codes. It's like watching FOX News but instead of cheerleading one side of ...

Ali's Choice

mrbrownstone wrote: ↑Sun Jul 13, 2025 1:21 am Fair to say Bryn Evans’ appointment as lineout coach is looking astute after some of the moves and trick plays we’ve pulled so far?

Our lineout looks better than it has since the peak Kieran Read era.

Ali's Choice

And if we're going to be talking about potential RWC squads in two years time, we've got to talk about who the ABs' second half-back is. At the moment, there's daylight between Roigard and the next best halfback. I think we'll take three halfbacks to the 2027 RWC, Roigard, Ratima and Hotham. Cam Ro...

Ali's Choice

Why is the 4th-best Lock Captain of the All Blacks? Is this based on 1-2 games against a sub-strength French team? It is. But Scott Barrett will need to lift his performance when he returns, otherwise this narrative will only get stronger with time. I mean he had a great SR season for the Crusaders...

Ali's Choice

xhooker wrote: ↑Sun Jul 13, 2025 12:24 am Why is the 4th-best Lock Captain of the All Blacks?

This is a ridiculous comment.

Ali's Choice

Monkey Magic wrote: ↑Sun Jul 13, 2025 12:58 am Tbf we said the same last year about our 6 issues being over once Sititi emerged.

Our backrow looks much more balanced with Vaa'i at 6, Sititi at 8 and Savea at 7.

Ali's Choice

Well I think we've found our next longterm no.6. Well done Scott Robertson, the AB's have been desperate for a blindside flanker since Jerome Kaino's loss of form prior to his departure, and Razor has found it in Tupou Vaa'i. Now he just needs to build cohesion in the midfield, and build depth off t...

Ali's Choice

My understanding is that you need to do weighted exercises for abs, with progressive overload to make them really “pop”. But we all have abs. I think emaciated POWs had just lost so much muscle all over—they weren’t getting anywhere near enough protein—that the abs they would have kept just disappe...

Ali's Choice

Abs might be further off than you think. Over the past decade and a half I’ve gone from 94 kgs to 70kgs. Even when I was at my leanest—68 kgs—abs were only just barely visible. I weighed in at 99.5kg at what I'd estimate at around 25/26% body fat - so would need to lose about 10kg overall to get to...

Ali's Choice

I'm not a fan of the rearranging the team for substitutions. It causes disruption and cohesion issues. Outside of injury players should be replaced directly. Having Kirifi on the bench as a substitute for Lio-Willie doesn't make sense. So just to clarify, your gripe of the day is that Robertson is ...

Ali's Choice

Nothing to do with age, he's just not as good as you're making out, he's a Super Rugby superstar and no better a test player than BB or DMac, and certainly not worthy of overhauling our eligibility laws like you and your fellow Cantabs want. Your opinion of Mo'unga means nothing. You've consistentl...

Ali's Choice

1. Williams 2. Taylor/Taukieaho (Taylor will be 36, need to keep an eye on how he ages) 3. Lomax 4. Barrett (c) 5. Holland 6. Vai'i 7. Savea 8. Sititi 9. Roigard 10. Mo'unga 11. Ioane 12. Jordie 13. Proctor 14. Narawa/Tangitau/Taumoefolau/A.N. Other 15. Jordan Yes please! Shut up and take my money!

Ali's Choice

Call me old fashioned but the halves pairings have traditionally been important for champion teams. Yep, and that's why Robertson has the two best 9's and 10's in NZ in his 23. I agree that McKenzie and BB have their limitations, and that's why I have consistently advocated for NZR to rethink their...

Ali's Choice

The great thing about this victory was how poorly we were rated. Nobody expected us to win. Even parochial QLD fans expected us to lose the series. Billy Slater is an absolute genius and the QLD spirit just came to the fore. Shibasaki and Papalii, what great stories.

Ali's Choice

Call me old fashioned but the halves pairings have traditionally been important for champion teams. Yep, and that's why Robertson has the two best 9's and 10's in NZ in his 23. I agree that McKenzie and BB have their limitations, and that's why I have consistently advocated for NZR to rethink their...

Ali's Choice

Go QLD! Great game last night. QLD win the deciding State of Origin game 24-12. Against all odds, in Sydney, in front of their women and children. Hear the lament! As a Cowboys fan it was great to see Tom Deardon win player of the match, and the Wally Lewis Medal for player of the series. So happy ...

Ali's Choice

Answer the question. Do you think this lineup has the potential to go through and win a World Cup? If they don't why bother sticking with a team that only manages to beat France B by a few points at home? You're unravelling now. Your trolling has been exposed for all to see. You just complain and t...

Ali's Choice

Some how I don't think suggestions on this forum aren't filtering up to Razor and co. Dumb post. You constantly suggest selections on this forum. We all do. Put up or shut up, what would your match day 23 be? You can't just complain and troll, actually offer some solutions. Do you honestly think th...

Ali's Choice

Go QLD! Great game last night. QLD win the deciding State of Origin game 24-12. Against all odds, in Sydney, in front of their women and children. Hear the lament! As a Cowboys fan it was great to see Tom Deardon win player of the match, and the Wally Lewis Medal for player of the series. So happy n...

Ali's Choice

Both Savea and Proctor specifically cost us with missed tackles and line breaks that lead to tries. Savea was involved in to bad defensive efforts for the Woki try. The team needs to be more physically aggressive in their defence collectively to stop France's forwards making easy metres. If they ca...

Ali's Choice

I long for a selection of players who don't ship 27 points against France B at home. Nebulous complaints with no suggestions for improvement help no one. Some how I don't think suggestions on this forum aren't filtering up to Razor and co. Dumb post. You constantly suggest selections on this forum....

Ali's Choice

So he's on England's payroll and will also presumably be refereeing England or games that impact England?

Ali's Choice

So good we shipped 27 points against a scratch France B team. Call me old fashioned but the best teams are built on great defence. So you long for constant and needless rotation, just for the sake of it? Thank God you aren't anywhere near the All Black selection table. I long for a selection of pla...

Ali's Choice

I think this is a good team. So good we shipped 27 points against a scratch France B team. Call me old fashioned but the best teams are built on great defence. So you long for constant and needless rotation, just for the sake of it? Thank God you aren't anywhere near the All Black selection table.

Ali's Choice

The usual Robertson haters will find fault with this team, as they will for every team he selects. It's getting boring, but it's expected as they have PTSD about Robertson because his Crusaders team pumped their useless Super Rugby teams year after year. I think this is a good team. We've had issue...

Ali's Choice

The usual Robertson haters will find fault with this team, as they will for every team he selects. It's getting boring, but it's expected as they have PTSD about Robertson because his Crusaders team pumped their useless Super Rugby teams year after year. I think this is a good team. We've had issue...

Ali's Choice

The usual Robertson haters will find fault with this team, as they will for every team he selects. It's getting boring, but it's expected as they have PTSD about Robertson because his Crusaders team pumped their useless Super Rugby teams year after year. I think this is a good team. We've had issues...

Ali's Choice

tubbyj wrote: ↑Sun Jul 06, 2025 1:29 am Still not sure how Ellison got promoted into this position on the worst Crusader season since the 1st last year.

Not sure how he was appointed? He won three SR titles as the Crusaders defense coach in 2021, 2022 and 2023.

Ali's Choice

Pretty hectic end to the game. Well done Wallabies. Hard luck Fiji.

Search found 41956 matches