Planet Rugby Forum

malky

Da iawn diolch wrote: ↑Wed Jul 02, 2025 11:28 am
irishrugbyua wrote: ↑Wed Jul 02, 2025 11:27 am targeting kicks at van der merwe.
That second try had absolutely nothing to do with him.

The desperation of some posters to find fault with him is astounding.
Completely ignoring several contributions that show why DVDM may well be starting in the Tests

malky

grimoald wrote: ↑Sat Jun 28, 2025 11:04 am Wtf was Cummings up to on that restart?

Not getting lifted high enough by his team mates

malky

Clearly the right call

malky

Plenty of tickets still on general sale despite the SRU claiming the game sold out months ago. They have been up since yesterday without being taken. They'll probably shift them all by kickoff but charging £150 for shite seats behind the goals it seems the SRU have found the limit of what they can ...

malky

Someone watched Squidge’s latest video. It’s to be expected when selecting players from such a wide variety of teams, there was 8 different clubs in the XV that played vs France. Scotland have Glasgow + Friends Ireland have Leinster + Leinster + NZ France have Toulouse SA have sharks and Rassies th...

malky

message #2527204 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 24, 2024 4:36 pm
AND-y wrote: ↑Sun Nov 24, 2024 4:36 pm wtf, this man has a scottish accent
Like haka for NZ, they give them lessons during the week

Not sure - maybe they’ve hired the guy that did that for England who led the way in poaching

malky

Do the Scottish crowd know the laws at all? As an Irishman you will understand that success attracts people who don’t necessarily understand the laws - many of your fellow posters from the Emerald Isle are poster kids for this. I am pleased that we have sold out 3 times and attracted over 61,000 ag...

malky

Do the Scottish crowd know the laws at all? As an Irishman you will understand that success attracts people who don’t necessarily understand the laws - many of your fellow posters from the Emerald Isle are poster kids for this. I am pleased that we have sold out 3 times and attracted over 61,000 ag...

malky

We should drop Jamie Ritchie more often…

malky

He still put his shoulder into White - penalty

malky

Both teams are making too many mistakes in the decision zone, it will come down to the one that finally manages to get two consecutive tries or 3 consecutive penalties I think. I am not to sure about the tackle vs maul decisions by the ref here. If it's a maul, then surely the Wanabes are bringing ...

malky

FFS That’s a penalty for pulling the maul down Busby

malky

ZuLurk wrote: ↑Sun Nov 10, 2024 5:50 pm Time wasting at the base

I love the 5 second rule - just questioning the application
It’s been working great giving the SH a warning so far this weekend

malky

Every ref so far this weekend has given the SH a 2 and 1 second warning…..but not tonight it seems.
And wasn’t Etsebeth technically offside before the 5 seconds was up which meant White had to delay?

malky

Watched it - real blow out at the end to be fair.
Argentina very impressive - would beat England at the moment I think

malky

At least we didn't lose to Italy. Matter of time - the rankings don’t lie - if you are regularly ranked 6 or 7 you’ll lose to Italy soon enough Scotland were ranked fifth, weren't they? No - after the unbalanced RWC Groups Scotland dropped to 6/7 due to the likes of England getting easy double poin...

malky

I’ve no idea what you mean by hyped or plastic hard men. We’ve been knowing they’re badly picked and organised since Borthwick. The rest stupid narrative by a wanker. Ah Bimbo, always flapping like a fůcked out fanny. Go and wipe down your mustard cords and write another letter to the Daily Mail. A...

malky

It's on trial at u20s, SR and some domestic comps, it is not an official law and hopefully never will be. It's in the RC too. Tbf, ive barely watched the RC. The second best thing tonight was Malky's moaning, only turns up when Scotland or a Scottish side looks like winning Moaning? I commented twi...

malky

Play acting - a penalty but sad to see the football antics

malky

Ref got that wrong- Ulster didn’t compete so not straight irrelevant

malky

Skiaddict wrote: ↑Fri Sep 20, 2024 8:09 pm He said use it. Clearly

Very clearly - it started moving forward after that - he can’t withdraw the ‘use it’

malky

IBWT wrote: ↑Sat Jul 06, 2024 5:55 pm Pearce evening up the ledger in about 2 minutes.

Referee continuing to have a good game getting the calls right against both teams

malky

Charger21 wrote: ↑Sat Jun 15, 2024 4:28 pm Think who ever wins this will be too f**ked for Munster or Glasgow next week

Are they just tossing a coin for who goes through then?

malky

Is POM fully retiring at the end of next season or is he going to do some TMO work?

malky

danny_fitz wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12, 2024 1:55 pm Newcastle literally win nothing and get a Challenge cup spot.

The more egregious story is the 2/3 Premiership teams that get places in the Champions Cup at the expense of more deserving and higher quality URC teams.

malky

Carly said onfield no try, should have been no try because it wasn't clear that the ball was grounded over the line from the video. Toulouse may feel hard done by there. That’s actually the protocol. Indeed ....and it was certainly apparently the protocol in the Scotland - France 6N match .....as m...

malky

Charger21 wrote: ↑Sat May 18, 2024 7:51 am At least they don't boo their own players
https://www.balls.ie/rugby/ian-keatley- ... ife-362409

Well that seems to have shut Diarm up!

The hypocrisy around booing from some Irish fans is remarkable
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Da7xPQflxiI

malky

Sounds like Rowntree knows they got lucky in the Snyman/Healy/Mata situation - respect to a proper rugby man who acknowledges you sometimes get the breaks!
Disappointed that Edinburgh didn’t get the breaks but it’s only a game - time for a good kip.

malky

It's a proper Owen Farrell tackle - one where the arms are notionally out to the side so it isn't clearly a tucked arm and shoulder, but in reality it is one where the player is looking to barge with the shoulder. Coombes should still be a little embarrassed mind. He's knocked slightly off balance ...

malky

:lol: :lol: :lol: I don't know what's funnier. Trying to pretend the booing was anything other than what it was, or how long you had to think back for a Scotland win in Dublin to find a dig. "Saw clearly on the replay that the arms were wrapped" https://i.imgur.com/ZwCXYTu.png https://x.com/PlanetR...

malky

Ferris? Is that who you're using? He embarrassed himself tonight with his anti Munster stance Seriously??? You people are unbelievable- it’s comical What did I say that was wrong? Have you got replays? Diarm has saved me the bother - he has kindly provided irrefutable evidence of a wrapped arm, the...

malky

I was about to say you're going to feel ashamed when you see a replay of it later. But I don't think shame is something you're capable of - mentioning soccer after the behaviour of your supporters this evening. It’s always amusing when pretend rugby fans don’t understand that the ‘booing’ by Edinbu...

malky

Coombes literally pulled the ref aside to ask him to have a look at it you clown. The Scottish co-commentator mentioned it as well before they cut back to show the lineout. If that was Coombes on a centre, it would've been a penalty try and a yellow card. Go back and have another look at it and sto...

malky

Coombes literally pulled the ref aside to ask him to have a look at it you clown. The Scottish co-commentator mentioned it as well before they cut back to show the lineout. If that was Coombes on a centre, it would've been a penalty try and a yellow card. Go back and have another look at it and sto...

malky

"Game changing error" = Munster having a lineout on the 5m line as opposed to on the 22. "Not a game changing error" = * No arms shoulder into touch by the last man preventing a try. * Dangerous high tackle before a turnover leading to first Edinburgh try. * Laughably obvious illegal turnover after...

malky

"Game changing error" = Munster having a lineout on the 5m line as opposed to on the 22. "Not a game changing error" = * No arms shoulder into touch by the last man preventing a try. * Dangerous high tackle before a turnover leading to first Edinburgh try. * Laughably obvious illegal turnover after...

malky

It is also amusing to imagine if that had been Ben Healy getting clattered in the same circumstances a year ago by Mata
100% reverse views guaranteed!

malky

Totally agree - what did Mata do out of interest? He barely touched Snyman as he dived over the players. Game changing error unfortunately He Was The Third Man In Dived On Top Of Snyman. If You Show Me A Still Of That - I’ll admit that you are correct He clearly dived over him

malky

3rd man in, as you know being such a rugby man, always gets the telling off. Totally agree - what did Mata do out of interest? He barely touched Snyman as he dived over the players. Game changing error unfortunately He Was The Third Man In Dived On Top Of Snyman. If You Show Me A Still Of That - I’...

malky

diarm wrote: ↑Fri May 17, 2024 10:02 pm
malky wrote: ↑Fri May 17, 2024 10:01 pm That replay of Mata in the Snyman/Healy incident!!!
That is never a penalty in a million years.
In your decades of rugby experience, you never saw the third man in to some handbags give away the penalty?

Must be a new thing for those fans off the boat.

What did Mata do that was a penalty?

Search found 2062 matches