Planet Rugby Forum

Magpie26

blindcider wrote: ↑Wed Mar 20, 2024 9:21 am
Masterji wrote: ↑Tue Mar 19, 2024 11:53 pm It will. Its the most sensible option. Too many games spoilt by Red cards
Nope, too many games spoilt by idiotic players.

So punish the players, not the fans who have spent time and money to watch a competitive game.

Magpie26

Mark from a restart sounds awful. Sounds like the game will get even slower if that's the case. 20 minute red cards....hmmm, just do what the NRL does. Give them a yellow and put them on report. In game red cards should be reserved for deliberately dangerous and foul play imo or a tackle that resul...

Magpie26

Almost as bad as our airforce unable to intercept a highjacked plane landing at Geneva..... because it happened outside of office hours

Magpie26

forrester wrote: ↑Mon Mar 18, 2024 9:44 am It was great to see Genge back and firing again.

I've said it before, sometimes he is everything you want to see in a modern prop, sometimes he shouldn't be anywhere near the England side.
Really pleasing to see him focusing on his game.
Best game from him in a long while

Magpie26

Just watched the u20s game.
Have to be fair, both the senior and junior games were cracking to watch.

Magpie26

ZuLurk wrote: ↑Sun Mar 17, 2024 4:15 am
Magpie26 wrote: ↑Sat Mar 16, 2024 8:12 pm
ZuLurk wrote: ↑Sat Mar 16, 2024 7:38 pm Boks nr1 on the World Rankings vs Ireland nr2 on the World Rankings.
The RWC winners vs 6Ns winners.
RC winners against 6N winners would have been better.
Haven't Ireland played a test series in nz in 2022?

They did and fully deserved their series win. They were very good.

Magpie26

Bit unlucky England, did much betterthan most expected

France, well its alright picking these huge lumps but when the game is played at pace too many of then fail to make enough of a contribution for me.

Magpie26

Come on, you guys know you are better than that, you are firmly part of the top 3 these days....no need to be dragged down to the cellar dwellers level.

Magpie26

Leinsterman wrote: ↑Sat Mar 16, 2024 8:45 pm
ZappaMan wrote: ↑Sat Mar 16, 2024 8:30 pm It's now 26 years since we won the Wooden Spoon. I bet the crowd had better craic coming last in '98 than first in 2024.
I can't even remember what it feels like to get a Wooden Spoon. Perhaps Henry can tell me what it feels like

Nasty.....but fair

Magpie26

iarmhiman wrote: ↑Sat Mar 16, 2024 8:36 pm Dublin is unaffordable for everyone except Americans these days

Not really.

Magpie26

Their Strength & Conditioning focus will kill a team like Ireland. :thumbup: You mean drugs yeah The Irish players need a good break to recharge and get away from rugby. Recharge and up the levels again against SA. Not easy being the best in the world (as Finn Russell just labelled us in his post m...

Magpie26

ZuLurk wrote: ↑Sat Mar 16, 2024 7:38 pm Boks nr1 on the World Rankings vs Ireland nr2 on the World Rankings.
The RWC winners vs 6Ns winners.

RC winners against 6N winners would have been better.

Magpie26

The baby Orcs played a great second half. They outclassed us and deserved their win. We had no answer to their maul, nor to the work of their scrum-half around the fringes where he created two winning gaps. All we had to respond was disjointed and brainless. It was very disappointing to see. Didn’t...

Magpie26

Well done Ireland, bloody hard work against a massively determined Scotland but got there in the end

Magpie26

Well that was probably the worst game in SR this year

Not helped by the worst reffing display either. He didn't favour one side over another, he was just terrible.

Magpie26

Chiefs attack was very slick at times, almost out Druaed the Drua.

Magpie26

Disappointing by the Landers.
Could have and maybe should have won it.
Unfortunately they looked like they were playing by numbers for most of the game. What a carry by Harmon for his try

Magpie26

I thought Love and Roigard were the pick of the Canes Backs, with Procter not far behind. Moorby looked dangerous but was well marked. Don't know if either team played to a game plan tonight. Love seems to have settled this year. No longer looking for the miracle play. He's a serious talent . Moorb...

Magpie26

Geez that was a tough win, but any win in Chch. Is a big one.
When the Saders got into their rhythm they were mighty hard to break down as they always are.
Reece was brilliant, easily MoM.

Magpie26

Pretty much. Internationals are meant to be better than pro leagues but I'm not sure these are. Interesting results but, as you say, quality is way down on what I expected My feeling too. Also winner was pretty much decided in the first game. By pretty much, you mean not at all? England were one sh...

Magpie26

One more game week to go. What are our thoughts? Entertaining but low on quality. Pretty much. Internationals are meant to be better than pro leagues but I'm not sure these are. Interesting results but, as you say, quality is way down on what I expected My feeling too. Also winner was pretty much d...

Magpie26

Very enjoyable, and the feel ‘of place’ is profound. Like the main guy - hardly perfect as hero which is attractive . She’s lovely and the rest of the cast particularly strong . As with the original mini series all the Japanese actors are great and carry the show. Didn't think Richard Chamberlain w...

Magpie26

Has there been a poor game yet? Yes! The Rebels were truly awful in their first outing against the Brumbies. The emotion got the better of the players I think and they shit the bed. It seems a bit of personal pride has kicked in and have pulled it back together in the last game and a half! True, ha...

Magpie26

The entertainment value has been excellent. Some great tries and close games. Reds and Tahs saw good crowds this weekend - maybe something is building? The Oz sides winning would be the best thing to happen for both countries. The re-emergence of Loud mouth, big-noting Oz fans is exactly what the c...

Magpie26

Blues had an absolute shocker and the Canes generally played well but the Blues were still somewhat in it, so I suppose there are positives in that, if they can learn and improve from this result. I hope they go back to the more basic approach of the first two games and try and grind teams down. Ca...

Magpie26

danny_fitz wrote: ↑Thu Mar 07, 2024 5:38 pm
Magpie26 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 07, 2024 3:35 pm TBH Ireland are really above 6N level at the moment, especially with France falling off a cliff.
They are more seen as part of the big 3 these days.
They really need to break away from the six nations and form their own competition

Ok, maybe they are not quite there yet.

Magpie26

Very well done Reds, looking very organised and well drilled this year

Magpie26

Zakar wrote: ↑Fri Mar 08, 2024 10:34 am Edmed good. Gleeson would be good if he didn't have tits for hands.

It's incredible you can play at this level yet still can't hold onto the ball. Seems to drop it far too regularly.

Was a pretty decent game overall

Magpie26

TBH Ireland are really above 6N level at the moment, especially with France falling off a cliff.
They are more seen as part of the big 3 these days.

Magpie26

https://www.sarugbymag.co.za/barrett-blacks-need-sa-super-rugby/ New Zealand playmaker Jordie Barrett has admitted that the All Blacks are poorer for not having South Africa involved in Super Rugby. Still just 27, Barrett celebrated his 100th game for the Hurricanes last weekend, which ended premat...

Magpie26

Well they do and did differentiate. No they didn't, they differentiated due to the 'absorbing nature of the tackle'. Did you even read the article :roll: Pretty hard to absorb a tackle while driving your shoulder into someone's face. But I meant they differentiated in terms of punishment. In other ...

Magpie26

Yes, I think head on head is less dangerous than shoulder to the head. Basic physics. I never said head to head wasn't also dangerous. Usually however head to head means there is at least some dip or control so it's more likely to lead to mitigation. Shoulder to head generally happens in a more rec...

Magpie26

Persia’s head bounced back. There was force there. Not sure how you can argue otherwise. I'm not say there wasn't force by Petia, I am saying there was little if any force by JB as he was basically stationary. Huh Barrett gets his shoulder into Petaias head which then snaps back from the impact. If...

Magpie26

If you can't see the difference, I can't help you. I think Porter might be marginal red with the bunker but Barrett is clear red. They're not the same, not least because one was a shoulder to head and one was head to head. Porter clearly trying to wrap and yes soak whereas by definition it's not a ...

Magpie26

He hit a bloke that wasn’t dipping with a shoulder to his head - the player left the field for a HIA and didn’t return. Barrett did have his feet planted, but I’m not sure what your point is, planting your feet is a way to execute big tackles. He didn't drive into the player, he was basically stati...

Magpie26

It's not a SH problem, it's a NH problem with its soak tackle approach. Have a look at the video, Porter doesn't go low, direct contact with the head, yet its not a red card because no force, a NH soak tackle. Looks very similar to JB to me. He was his feet planted, with perhaps a small sideways sh...

Magpie26

Just looked at it there and I can see why the SH might have a problem if there's any complaints about that being red. It's a stone cold red and has been up here for years. No attempt whatsoever to go low, contact with the head, completely reckless. It's not a SH problem, it's a NH problem with its ...

Magpie26

Players don't (or shouldn't) get red cards for accidental high hits. They get red cards for going too high, recklessly, with force . If it was random then all teams would be getting red cards in equal measures and there'd be a random distribution amongst the players. This isn't the case. I agree th...

Magpie26

Players don't (or shouldn't) get red cards for accidental high hits. They get red cards for going too high, recklessly, with force . If it was random then all teams would be getting red cards in equal measures and there'd be a random distribution amongst the players. This isn't the case. I agree th...

Magpie26

Players don't (or shouldn't) get red cards for accidental high hits. They get red cards for going too high, recklessly, with force . If it was random then all teams would be getting red cards in equal measures and there'd be a random distribution amongst the players. This isn't the case. I agree th...

Search found 4562 matches