Page 1 of 2

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 12:31 pm
by Kahu
Like fudge he is.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 12:31 pm
by globus
I'm so very pleased for him. An England stalwart.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 12:47 pm
by HKCJ
Oh how we all laughed at DCM back in the day

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 12:50 pm
by globus
HKCJ wrote:Oh how we all laughed at DCM back in the day
Rule 1.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast-medium bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 12:50 pm
by Dobbin
Fixed

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:00 pm
by Joost
He seemed genuinely happy yesterday, which is a first - reminded me of when the England team had to draw cartoons of each other and a couple of people did Jimmy...

Image

Image

His one of Swanny was also pretty accurate:

Image

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:00 pm
by kiwigreg369
globus wrote:
HKCJ wrote:Oh how we all laughed at DCM back in the day
Rule 1.
Possibly ironic in a Jimmy Saville kinda way.

------

As for Jimmy .. well Glenn McGrath is a Cock.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:01 pm
by globus
I'll go with "pace" bowler. It's a great achievement, however you want to place him, in the van of other luminaries.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:10 pm
by Boris
He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:13 pm
by Sandstorm
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
He was horribly underused by England from 2003-2008. Had he been selected more often & bowled more, he'd be right up near Warnie I reckon. :nod:

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:14 pm
by globus
Ovals. Verdict?

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:17 pm
by Frodder
guy smiley wrote:
Sandstorm wrote:
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
He was horribly underused by England from 2003-2008. Had he been selected more often & bowled more, he'd be right up near Warnie I reckon. :nod:

A contender then, for the Greatest Bowler Of All Time. :nod:
Correct and he's got a better batting average than McGrath

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:18 pm
by globus
guy smiley wrote:
Sandstorm wrote:
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
He was horribly underused by England from 2003-2008. Had he been selected more often & bowled more, he'd be right up near Warnie I reckon. :nod:

A contender then, for the Greatest Bowler Of All Time. :nod:
Hat's off to him. A proper John Steed.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:21 pm
by fatcat
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.
I was looking at the progression of his average yesterday. I think it's 24 point odd for the last 10 years and improves every time you knock off the oldest year of the range up until the last year, eg. 21 over the last 5 years, 18 over the last 2. It's remarkable how he's consistently improved to such a level.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:29 pm
by etherman
Terrific bowler with immense skill. His control of swing is incredible. Some of his wickets this series were just perfection. When you talk about the best there's lots of ways of making that judgement but longevity and consistency are as valuable as being sh!t hot for 5 years. If you look at the gap in quality between broad Anderson and the rest for england over the last 5/6 years you can see how screwed they have been with out him. I like the cut of his gib too. No histrionics or celeb nonsense from him a la KP etc. He'll not be doing Strictly.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:33 pm
by globus
etherman wrote:He'll not be doing Strictly.
Oi. Hang on. I can see him waltzing all over the place. But his "Quickstep" will be to behold.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:53 pm
by Saint
fatcat wrote:
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.
I was looking at the progression of his average yesterday. I think it's 24 point odd for the last 10 years and improves every time you knock off the oldest year of the range up until the last year, eg. 21 over the last 5 years, 18 over the last 2. It's remarkable how he's consistently improved to such a level.
He's spent a lot of time recovering from the early days where for some reason the English bowling coaches kept trying to alter his natural action, which gave him masses of control and once he got it back resulted in all of those wickets. The way they screwed around with him in the early days was criminal

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 1:55 pm
by iarmhiman
He's no Andy Caddick

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 2:06 pm
by etherman
iarmhiman wrote:He's no Andy Caddick
Carrick must have one of the most mealey mouthed profiles on Cric info:
Irresistible on his day, Caddick can also be frustratingly mediocre -especially for England. But for Somerset he is as consistently destructive as any overseas player, even on the belters at Taunton. His action is modelled on Richard Hadlee's, and Caddick sometimes bowls as well as him, finding bounce and movement from just short of a length. He's a sensitive man, though, and if a batsman gets after him his confidence can vanish. He has been called gauche, aloof, and - by his former England coach David Lloyd - nerdy. He retired from one-day cricket after the 2003 World Cup. Despite taking 105 wickets in 1998, he was not wanted for the Ashes tour. But under Nasser Hussain and Duncan Fletcher, Caddick flourished, and formed a strong partnership with Darren Gough that lasted 25 Tests, faltered only during the 2001 Ashes drubbing, and was finally broken when both men decided not to go to India in November 2001. Caddick left his decision until the last minute. Although in the international wilderness, he continued to plug away for Somerset with good results. There is no doubt that he is more of a team man than he used to be. Except when he's running between the wickets. Caddick finished the 2007 season as the leading English wicket-taker but, during an injury-plagued 2008 season, finally admitted that his England days were over. He announced he would retire from first-class cricket at the end of 2009 season.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 2:30 pm
by Working Class Rugger
It's a great achievement but Glen McGrath did it less Tests. Therefore he remains the G.O.A.T

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 2:37 pm
by Working Class Rugger
guy smiley wrote:
Working Class Rugger wrote:It's a great achievement but Glen McGrath did it less Tests. Therefore he remains the G.O.A.T
Finally, after all these years, an Australian admits Hadlee's superior strike rate makes him better than McGrath.

This thread... well, I'm so proud.
Better him than an Englishman.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 2:46 pm
by booze
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.
Boris, you will find a majority of bowlers have similar improvements as they hone their craft.

Anderson is an outstanding bowler but his strike rate and average are not as good as other greats

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 2:57 pm
by Sandstorm
booze wrote:
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.
Boris, you will find a majority of bowlers have similar improvements as they hone their craft.

Anderson is an outstanding bowler but his strike rate and average are not as good as other greats
It would be much higher if he didn't have Cook dropping so many catches at 1st slip.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 2:58 pm
by LandOTurk
booze wrote:
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.
Boris, you will find a majority of bowlers have similar improvements as they hone their craft.

Anderson is an outstanding bowler but his strike rate and average are not as good as other greats
I would suspect that when McGrath has Warne bowling too, the pressure on the batsmen is that much greater. It would have some influcnce on teh average. I am not saying very sgnificantly, but still something.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:02 pm
by LandOTurk
Jimmy has 564 wickets from 143 games over 15 years
Broad has 433 wickets from 123 games over 11 years

http://stats.espncricinfo.com/wi/conten ... 93276.html

Broad may overtake Jimmy.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:21 pm
by fatcat
booze wrote:
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.
Boris, you will find a majority of bowlers have similar improvements as they hone their craft.

Anderson is an outstanding bowler but his strike rate and average are not as good as other greats
Not quite with McGrath though. He had small improvements over the fist few years (in his average) and it was up and down after that. Plus he's a cock.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:26 pm
by RodneyRegis
Broad would need to play another 37 matches at that rate. He's played 11 matches per year, so he'd need another 3 or 4 years. He's 32 now. Doubt it.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:26 pm
by Macrosan
guy smiley wrote:
Working Class Rugger wrote:It's a great achievement but Glen McGrath did it less Tests. Therefore he remains the G.O.A.T
Finally, after all these years, an Australian admits Hadlee's superior strike rate makes him better than McGrath.

This thread... well, I'm so proud.
Hadlee didn’t have a Warne bowking at the other end you plum.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:27 pm
by RodneyRegis
fatcat wrote:
booze wrote:
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.
Boris, you will find a majority of bowlers have similar improvements as they hone their craft.

Anderson is an outstanding bowler but his strike rate and average are not as good as other greats
Not quite with McGrath though. He had small improvements over the fist few years (in his average) and it was up and down after that. Plus he's a cock.
Image

:)

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:37 pm
by sturginho
How do we all think his chances are of overtaking Kumble on the list? He needs about 50 or so right?

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:38 pm
by Working Class Rugger
guy smiley wrote:
Macrosan wrote:
guy smiley wrote:
Working Class Rugger wrote:It's a great achievement but Glen McGrath did it less Tests. Therefore he remains the G.O.A.T
Finally, after all these years, an Australian admits Hadlee's superior strike rate makes him better than McGrath.

This thread... well, I'm so proud.
Hadlee didn’t have a Warne bowking at the other end you plum.
Well yes, which makes Hadlee's performance even more impressive. You seem to screw up with every second post you make. Are you from South Africa?
Yeah, I was trying to figure out exactly what point he was trying to make. Would have thought having one of the best spinners ever working in tandem would have been to his advantage.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:41 pm
by blindcider
Working Class Rugger wrote:
guy smiley wrote:
Macrosan wrote:
guy smiley wrote:
Working Class Rugger wrote:It's a great achievement but Glen McGrath did it less Tests. Therefore he remains the G.O.A.T
Finally, after all these years, an Australian admits Hadlee's superior strike rate makes him better than McGrath.

This thread... well, I'm so proud.
Hadlee didn’t have a Warne bowking at the other end you plum.
Well yes, which makes Hadlee's performance even more impressive. You seem to screw up with every second post you make. Are you from South Africa?
Yeah, I was trying to figure out exactly what point he was trying to make. Would have thought having one of the best spinners ever working in tandem would have been to his advantage.
i guess he's arguing that Warne took wickets that McGrath could have done without acknoweldging that its not a zero sum game and the fact that McGrath had world class bowlers around him reduced the pressure on him to perform.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 3:54 pm
by zzzz
Anderson will out do Kumble before he retires.

And McGrath got a lot more wickets from bowling alongside Warne than he lost.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 4:09 pm
by booze
LandOTurk wrote:
booze wrote:
Boris wrote:He has improved dramatically over his career:

Pre 2008: 62 wickets; average 39.2; strike rate 62.7
2008-2013: 278 wickets; average 28.7; strike rate 58.4
2014 onwards: 224 wickets; average 21.1; strike rate 50.7

Over the last few years, he has been among the best quick bowlers in the world. Steyn and Rabada have much lower strike rates though.
Boris, you will find a majority of bowlers have similar improvements as they hone their craft.

Anderson is an outstanding bowler but his strike rate and average are not as good as other greats
I would suspect that when McGrath has Warne bowling too, the pressure on the batsmen is that much greater. It would have some influcnce on teh average. I am not saying very sgnificantly, but still something.
plenty of scenarios, that supports arguments. anderson bowling with a duke in english conditions, mcgrath on aus wickets, Dev on indian dustbowls. Anderson has benefited in recent years from batsman who struggle with test match conditions now that T20 has taken over. Hadlee's back up was a big drop in class so far less ability to build pressure at the other end.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 4:13 pm
by blindcider
One thing I think is difficult to argue against is that if you are selecting a hypothetical all time XI to play a test match at Lords you would be picking Jimmy Anderson.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 4:21 pm
by booze
blindcider wrote:One thing I think is difficult to argue against is that if you are selecting a hypothetical all time XI to play a test match at Lords you would be picking Jimmy Anderson.
hypothetically no. Lille and Hadlee to open the bowling ;-)


With test cricket under such threat I doubt that this record number of wickets for a fast bowler will ever be beaten. We can talk about averages etc but Anderson has the most wickets by a fast bowler probably foerver.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 4:47 pm
by Rowdy
booze wrote:
blindcider wrote:One thing I think is difficult to argue against is that if you are selecting a hypothetical all time XI to play a test match at Lords you would be picking Jimmy Anderson.
hypothetically no. Lille and Hadlee to open the bowling ;-)


With test cricket under such threat I doubt that this record number of wickets for a fast bowler will ever be beaten. We can talk about averages etc but Anderson has the most wickets by a fast bowler probably foerver.
Hypothetically, wherever the game is played, you would open with Marshall and Ambrose.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 5:05 pm
by etherman
An article from 2011, mid career jimmy. Really impressive figures: http://www.espncricinfo.com/magazine/co ... 24185.html

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 5:11 pm
by Masterji
Jimmy is a great bowler and his stats are brilliant but in all conditions i wouldnt put him as a top 10 bowler.

Re: Jimmy Anderson... world's greatest fast bowler

Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2018 5:45 pm
by LandOTurk
RodneyRegis wrote:Broad would need to play another 37 matches at that rate. He's played 11 matches per year, so he'd need another 3 or 4 years. He's 32 now. Doubt it.
Jimmy is 36.