Page 2 of 2

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Thu May 14, 2020 1:57 am
by frillage
HKCJ wrote:If I find out you’re building a secret underground power station in the New Town slick there’ll be hell to pay
I heard he was trying to sell Dounreay to Africa.

Re: 750 mW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 7:23 pm
by Uncle Fester
A5D5E5 wrote:
Uncle Fester wrote:
A5D5E5 wrote:
Spyglass wrote:
slick wrote:
I did, thanks.

So pretty chunky then?

I have some follow up questions if you, or anyone else, knows about these things....

What kind of size would that power station be? Say in terms of rugby pitches?

Any ideas of costs of decommissioning, moving (overseas) and putting back together again - appreciate this would be very, very rough.
Typical power densities of various types of power plants are:

Gas CCGT: 80MW/acre
Nuclear: 30MW/acre
Coal: 10MW/acre
Wind/Solar: <1MW/acre

Obviously some generalizations in these numbers and modern H technology CCGT plants would be higher than the 80MW/acre

As for plant relocations, this makes some sense for stranded low operating hours gas turbine assets (we used to do quite a lot of these but this market has dried up due to the reduced price of new gas turbines), but the economics don't really work for coal, as it's difficult to relocate the boilers, fuel handling etc. There are too many variables to give a meaningful cost estimate.
Am I the only person who loves the mixing of SI and imperial units in this way?
30 metres of 4 inch pipe okay for you luv?
Thanks. Put it over there with the 8' x 4' 18mm ply and 3.6m 2x4s.
I love metric but when it comes to pipe sizing, inch OD is your only man.
There's a poor dairy somewhere in Ireland that has to go to Germany for all their spare parts because a certain engineer in his youthful enthusiasm decided the whole place should be specced with DIN pipe.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 7:59 pm
by Nolanator
Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 9:32 pm
by happyhooker
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
for domestic plumbing in the uk, including gas, we now use metric measurements, but you can hook up imperial kit with no problem 99% of the time

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 9:37 pm
by Saint
happyhooker wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
for domestic plumbing in the uk, including gas, we now use metric measurements, but you can hook up imperial kit with no problem 99% of the time

Yeah - when we retrofitted underfloor heating last summer, the new pipework was metric, but had to hook into the original imperial. One 69 pence convertor and some quick welding later, all sorted

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 9:53 pm
by happyhooker
Saint wrote:
happyhooker wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
for domestic plumbing in the uk, including gas, we now use metric measurements, but you can hook up imperial kit with no problem 99% of the time

Yeah - when we retrofitted underfloor heating last summer, the new pipework was metric, but had to hook into the original imperial. One 69 pence convertor and some quick welding later, all sorted
even works on most compression and pushfit (for water, obvs)

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 9:59 pm
by Nolanator
happyhooker wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
for domestic plumbing in the uk, including gas, we now use metric measurements, but you can hook up imperial kit with no problem 99% of the time
Makes sense, it'll all be metric eventually. What about industrial/commercial?

It's handy because you can fit a 6mm pipe into 1/4" furrules and connect to a 1/4" fitting. So newer pipes can fit into older equipment. Can't go the other way, though.
Then some arse mixes up the bits and you end up digging through the nuts looking for the ring that denotes metric dimensions, or poking a pipe offcut through ferrules/nuts to see what works.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 10:04 pm
by happyhooker
Nolanator wrote:
happyhooker wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
for domestic plumbing in the uk, including gas, we now use metric measurements, but you can hook up imperial kit with no problem 99% of the time
Makes sense, it'll all be metric eventually. What about industrial/commercial?

It's handy because you can fit a 6mm pipe into 1/4" furrules and connect to a 1/4" fitting. So newer pipes can fit into older equipment. Can't go the other way, though.
Then some arse mixes up the bits and you end up digging through the nuts looking for the ring that denotes metric dimensions, or poking a pipe offcut through ferrules/nuts to see what works.
yea, thise as well. i've built a few breweries in places that were originally fitted out in imperial. no problem apart from the initial annoyance that you'd been lied to by the property agent

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 10:11 pm
by Lord Denning
The foot-poundal is a unit that no one will ever miss.

Along with groats, guineas, morgens and cow’s grass.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 10:42 pm
by Uncle Fester
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
Not specialist at all, just general piping. DN80 and 3" pipe cannot be welded directly together in a hygienic way. You'll end up with an ugly lip where dirt and contamination can collect at best and quite probably a shit weld that will fail easily. You'll get away with jimmys if it's not a hygienic application though.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Mon May 18, 2020 11:53 pm
by happyhooker
Uncle Fester wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
Not specialist at all, just general piping. DN80 and 3" pipe cannot be welded directly together in a hygienic way. You'll end up with an ugly lip where dirt and contamination can collect at best and quite probably a shit weld that will fail easily. You'll get away with jimmys if it's not a hygienic application though.
i think nols works in a lab environment where 3" pipe is something the geeks dream about having

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Tue May 19, 2020 7:58 am
by Nolanator
Yep. Cooling is in 3/4", process gases in 1/4".

No need for anything bigger.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Tue May 19, 2020 3:14 pm
by Spyglass
Uncle Fester wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
Not specialist at all, just general piping. DN80 and 3" pipe cannot be welded directly together in a hygienic way. You'll end up with an ugly lip where dirt and contamination can collect at best and quite probably a shit weld that will fail easily. You'll get away with jimmys if it's not a hygienic application though.
Provided they are the same Schedule, DN80 and 3"NB pipes have the same dimensions, so provided you use the correct welding procedure and it's executed by a qualified welder, it will be a perfectly good joint.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Tue May 19, 2020 7:52 pm
by Uncle Fester
Spyglass wrote:
Uncle Fester wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
Not specialist at all, just general piping. DN80 and 3" pipe cannot be welded directly together in a hygienic way. You'll end up with an ugly lip where dirt and contamination can collect at best and quite probably a shit weld that will fail easily. You'll get away with jimmys if it's not a hygienic application though.
Provided they are the same Schedule, DN80 and 3"NB pipes have the same dimensions, so provided you use the correct welding procedure and it's executed by a qualified welder, it will be a perfectly good joint.
Inch OD dairy 1.5mm wall thickness tubing is problematic to match up with metric.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Tue May 19, 2020 8:47 pm
by Spyglass
Uncle Fester wrote:
Spyglass wrote:
Uncle Fester wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
Not specialist at all, just general piping. DN80 and 3" pipe cannot be welded directly together in a hygienic way. You'll end up with an ugly lip where dirt and contamination can collect at best and quite probably a shit weld that will fail easily. You'll get away with jimmys if it's not a hygienic application though.
Provided they are the same Schedule, DN80 and 3"NB pipes have the same dimensions, so provided you use the correct welding procedure and it's executed by a qualified welder, it will be a perfectly good joint.
Inch OD dairy 1.5mm wall thickness tubing is problematic to match up with metric.
Ahh I see where the confusion arises, you initially mentioned 3" pipe (pipe sizing standards refer to bore), whereas you meant 3" tube (tube sizing standards refer to the OD). You would need a transition piece to join a 3" pipe to a 3" tube, even if they were the same schedule (wall thickness).

Either way, 1.5mm wall thickness is a very thin for a 3" tube....very low design pressure

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Tue May 19, 2020 11:14 pm
by Nolanator
Never knew that distinction between piping and tubing. :thumbup:
Everything we use is tubing but hadn't realised what that specifically meant, although I'd presumed there was a reason.

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Tue May 19, 2020 11:19 pm
by BlackMac
Looking at the size of my bloody energy bill, it would appear to be the amount used to power and heat my house for 3 months. :x

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Wed May 20, 2020 7:42 pm
by Uncle Fester
Spyglass wrote:
Uncle Fester wrote:
Spyglass wrote:
Uncle Fester wrote:
Nolanator wrote:Is it specialist equipment or infrastructure? Swagelok supply both, so it's not an issue sourcing metric fittings.

We use a shit load of 1/4" SS piping, but we purchased a huge portion of our equipment from a Finnish company, who deal.in metric. Can cause issues the odd time, bit it's mostly ok.

In my PhD group, some equipment had been brought over from Germany (metric), while some had been purchased through Irish/UK vendors (imperial). All house gas lines were in imperial. Bit daft at times, especially considering how close 1/4" and 6mm are.
Not specialist at all, just general piping. DN80 and 3" pipe cannot be welded directly together in a hygienic way. You'll end up with an ugly lip where dirt and contamination can collect at best and quite probably a shit weld that will fail easily. You'll get away with jimmys if it's not a hygienic application though.
Provided they are the same Schedule, DN80 and 3"NB pipes have the same dimensions, so provided you use the correct welding procedure and it's executed by a qualified welder, it will be a perfectly good joint.
Inch OD dairy 1.5mm wall thickness tubing is problematic to match up with metric.
Ahh I see where the confusion arises, you initially mentioned 3" pipe (pipe sizing standards refer to bore), whereas you meant 3" tube (tube sizing standards refer to the OD). You would need a transition piece to join a 3" pipe to a 3" tube, even if they were the same schedule (wall thickness).

Either way, 1.5mm wall thickness is a very thin for a 3" tube....very low design pressure
You can tell I'm process rather than mech eng, can't you! ;-)

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Wed May 20, 2020 7:54 pm
by slick
Got a coal fired one to sell as well now if anyone is interested?

Re: 750 MW

Posted: Wed May 20, 2020 8:56 pm
by Spyglass
Uncle Fester wrote: You can tell I'm process rather than mech eng, can't you! ;-)
I just can't understand how us engineers get the reputation for being anally retentive..... :lol: